American Idol Top 12 BoysFebruary 24, 2010
“I guess Simon was right about the girls being better this year. The problem with the boys was the lack of overall originality or star factor. Even the favorites were either safe, too creative or over-sang their songs. There was definitely a lack of confidence and a lot of nerves. None of the guys really struck the right cord with me; however there were some who were able to rise above it al:”
The scores are based on vocal ability, appearance, song choice, personality, stage presence and impact out of a possible 30 points! EPIC (29-30) GREAT (27-28) GOOD (25-26) OK (23-25) FAIL (22 and below)
Here are the girl’s grades in order of performance:
Todrick Hall – 25 Super-confident and completely changed up the song! Points for being creative, but in this case, the original was way better!!
Aaron Kelly – 27 He has a big ole country voice, but he reminds me so much of Kevin Covais and I am trying to connect the image with the voice.
Jermaine Sellers – 24 Started rough and remained there throughout. He showed a lot of personality but did too much with the song.
Tim Urban – 21 He started ok but fell apart with his horrible falsetto. The song was way too big for him.
Joe Munoz – 24 He looked confident but his voice sounded so nervous and had a vibrating quality to it. I don’t know if that’s really how he sings since this is the first full performance I have seen of him, but he has potential.
Tyler Grady – 24 Second-rate Jim Morrison wannabe and it came off as trying hard.
Lee Dewyze – 26 I liked the arrangement and although there were some rough patches, he showcased an amazing voice!
John Park – 23 Another rough start. Too many nerves and although he kind of came back, It was too late!
Michael Lynche – 25 I wish he didn’t have the guitar because it looked like a prop. He could have worked the stage instead. He was good but it was a safe performance that stood out amidst the lukewarm group.
Alex Lambert – 23 He has a good voice but he seemed so uncomfortable and didn’t know what to do in front of the camera.
Casey James – 27 I thought his performance was somewhat overshadowed by Kara and what was going on in the judges panel. Despite that he was definitely very good at tackling the song and did a really good job.
And the pimp spot award goes to…..
Andrew Garcia– 28 Of course, being my favorite contestant so far, I would be biased but I thought he did an amazing job. The song choice was interesting and I felt like he picked the most random song to make work and he should have picked an easier song to take out of the park.
My top 12:
- Andrew Garcia
- Casey James
- Aaron Kelly
- Lee Dewyze
- Michael Lynche
- Todrick Hall
- Joe Munoz
- Tyler Grady
- Jermaine Sellers
- Alex Lambert
- John Park
- Tim Urban
Final Thoughts: The guys were definitely a weaker bunch and my favorites didn’t really shine as much as I would have liked to. Andrew took the pimp spot as expected and although he picked an unusual song, I think he picked the right song to attract the attention of the younger audience as well as showcase his unique ability to make a song his own. Aaron and Casey stood out among the bunch while John who was one of my favorites and Tim are the likely two who will leave in the elimination show. Both picked the wrong songs and fell flat. Alex should also worry because of his awkward performance but his strong and unique vocals could keep him around.
Update: Joe and Tyler are out! Surprise surprise!! I guess it would make sense considering the guys in general were pretty weak so surprises were expected. Joe was unfortunate because he never got enough coverage to really stand out and his moment wasn’t a strong one. Tyler on the other hand had such an interesting personality. I just think his second-rate Jim Morrison was the reason for his demise, another case of song choice.