American Idol Top 10 BoysMarch 2, 2010
“Despite having less time to prepare this week due to the switch of nights, I felt for the most part the guys stepped up and a lot of them are standing out as potential front-runners and upsets. The biggest fail this week were the judges. Why do some contestants have to sing the original version while others need to change it up and make it new. Hasn’t the latter been what American Idol is about. David Cook, Kris Allen, Adam Lambert all did and they won, so what is going on? I almost feel like they are either agreeing with their fellow judges or trying to say something different for the sake of saying something different. If i were a contestant i would be so confused. How can i get better if i get complete opposites with what I am being told. Did i do good or was i bad? Although the judges weren’t on top of their game this week, the boys were!”
The scores are based on vocal ability, appearance, song choice, personality, stage presence and impact out of a possible 30 points! EPIC (29-30) GREAT (27-28) GOOD (25-26) OK (23-25) FAIL (22 and below)
Here are the guys grades in order of performance:
Michael Lynche 29
If last week was the supporting act, this week was the main show and a completely different person and performer.
John Park 24
He was definitely a lot better than last week but it was a safe and forgettable performance for someone who is trying to stand out.
Casey James 26
He is amazing on the guitar but was nowhere near the caliber of Elliot Yamin or Bo Bice!
Alex Lambert 29
This performance was night and day compared to last week and i predicted something like this could happen. His voice rivals that of Jason Mraz and John Mayer, but can easily be identifiable if recorded. I knew if he survived this week and got better with his stage presence he could do something good and that’s exactly what he did!
Todrick Hall 24
He took a different turn from last week. Although he showed more of his vocals, his personality disappeared. There were too many runs and he does too much to the song.
Jermaine Sellers 25
Jermaine had a good point about church. I almost feel like the judges just don’t understand gospel/rnb voices. I felt emotion I just don’t think he did the song justice.
Andrew Garcia 25
I didn’t get it. Last week was more on the lines of what to expect from Andrew but the wrong song choice. This week was just blah. Has he already lost his flair?
Aaron Kelly 26
He had a weird vibration to his voice this week that kind of lingered all throughout. More personality but vocally not as good as last week. Didn’t see what the judges did!
Tim Urban 23
I still don’t get him. I totally agree with Ellen here. His voice is nothing different than we have heard before and if he stays it’ll be because of his looks because his voice is definitely not a reason. His reaction to Simon’s comments were funny. Sorry Tim, all Simon really said was that you were better than last week.. that’s not saying too much when 3/4 of your fellow competitors did too.
Lee Dewyze 27
This guy has a phenomenal voice and look and if there were pitchy parts, I didn’t hear them just because of the tone of his voice that makes it acceptable. With or without his guitar he can do no wrong!
My top 10:
- Michael Lynche
- Alex Lambert
- Lee Dewyze
- Casey James
- Aaron Kelly
- Jermaine Sellers
- Andrew Garcia
- Todrick Hall
- John Park
- Tim Urban
Final Thoughts: Considering last week’s Joe Munoz was really the only one who had the least amount of TV coverage, that wouldn’t apply this week. Instead it boils down to who stepped up the most. Alex could have easily been in the next wave to go but his incredible improvement may have saved him at least for another week. I think John Park and Tim Urban are the weakest among the bunch although both slightly improved over last week. Falling in the category of doing too much are Todrick and Jermaine who could easily switch places with either of the two who I predict to be eliminated this week!
Update: John and Jermaine are out. Tim stays another week? Is this really looks or are people hearing something i don’t. Both John and Jermaine are so much better singers but just didn’t make that connection with the audience.