American Idol Top 12March 16, 2010
“Overall the top 12 was pretty good as a whole, but I didn’t see essence of The Rolling Stones in most of the performances. I was expecting more energy and rock n roll. At least the contestants were able to show their true colors through their arrangements which is commendable. If this competition were a battle of the sexes, the girls definitely ruled tonight with a perfect performance by Siobhan Magnus”
The scores are based on vocal ability, appearance, song choice, personality, stage presence and impact out of a possible 30 points! EPIC (29-30) GREAT (27-28) GOOD (25-26) OK (23-25) FAIL (22 and below)
Here are the guy’s grades in order of performance:
Michael Lynche 28
His confidence is definitely showing and his stage presence is very powerful. However, I was hoping he would stick to his new formal style and keep to the suits, but besides that it was good but not as good as last week.
Didi Benami 27
She has such a unique voice and she remained consistent from last week. Somehow she does so much better when her performance his stripped down with a guitar.
Casey James 28
This is definitely the type of music style that suits Casey. The bluesy-country style! Although vocally he was good, I would have preferred more use of the stage. Sometimes even if you stand in one spot, you could own the stage. I just didn’t feel that from him.
Lacey Brown 25
She did okay, but it still baffles me how she made it in over Katelyn and Lilly!! Besides that, she didn’t do anything different and I did notice that she like to sit on the edge of the stage. It worked before, but maybe a different approach next time.
Andrew Garcia 26
Andrew is my Danny Gokey of this year. I was a huge fan!!! Only difference is while I was drawn away from Danny fan-club midway through the season after I became bored, I am already over Andrew. After Straight Up, nothing has been the same and I feel that his time will be coming very soon if he continues down this rut.
Katie Stevens 27
She was definitely far improved from previous weeks, however, I was comparing her rendition to Susan Boyle’s and it was somewhat off. It was good in parts, but overall a big improvement.
Tim Urban 25
His vocals have definitely improved and after last week, he has improved considerably. However, it was an interesting song choice for me and the arrangement was quite odd!
Siobhan Magnus 30
This girl is amazing. Her vocal range is outstanding. The performance was dramatic and that last note was out of this world. She looked amazing in her Harajuku-esque style and this was definitely her best performance.
Lee Dewyze 27
He definitely stands out in his own way and I agree that he needs to break out more. With that voice he can rock it out, but he remained safe but sure. If it works it works, but he can take it a step further.
Paige Miles 27
For someone who had laryngitis this week she did an amazing job especially considering her poor vocals last week. The performance was okay, but she did mention this was her first real practice this week. Being the one that counts, she did a good job
Aaron Kelly 28
Aaron was great this week. His vocals were on point and he really connected to this song which made it more believable and stand out.
Crystal Bowersox 28
There is nobody quite like this girl and even her off-performance is miles better over other performers. She may have not delivered her best, but considering she is such a strong favorite, there is so much expectations from her that anything negative can be blown out of proportion.
My top 12:
- Siobhan Magnus
- Aaron Kelly
- Casey James
- Crystal Bowersox
- Michael Lynche
- Didi Benami
- Lee Dewyze
- Katie Stevens
- Paige Miles
- Andrew Garcia
- Lacey Brown
- Tim Urban
Final Thoughts: Siobhan Magnus was the unexpected star of the night delivering a standout performance from start to end. Crystal may have been off her game but was still good. Lacey and Tim showed why they shouldn’t be in the competition and either should be the first casualty in the top 12. However, Paige’s laryngitis may also play into the voting. Her top 12 placement was also unexpected and she may also be up for elimination.
Result: No surprises here. Tim, Lacey and Paige were in the bottom three. Tim was the first one who was safe with Lacey and Paige in the bottom 2. Lacey was eliminated and the judges chose to let her go. Once again, a wasted spot for someone else. In the end the judges were right no the mark.