Last week, my TIVO forgot to record American Idol on the most important night for the show and the contestants as to who made the top 10. The top 10 will go on tour for the next year and will actually be able to pursue their dreams as a singer. The problem is, do we care? For all of the drama and selection of the top 24, this is probably the weakest top 10 in the history of American Idol. I have this feeling that the mass voters and the people who actually spend money on the artists and have something to say about American Idol are two completely different groups of people.
It’s still hard to believe that we lost Lily Scott, Katelyn Epperly, Todrick Hall and Alex Lambert just a few weeks ago! Anyone of these 4 contestants (I won’t even go into people who should have made the top 24) should have made the top 10 over some less than notable contestants like Katie Stevens and Tim Urban. These two are prime examples of contestants that have made it through on their appeal to connect to the audience because they’re cute. This doesn’t mean they will be successful. I can go a step further and say that Kris Allen had it all, looks and the voice, but look what happened to him. I know more people that remember him as the guy on the FORD commercial than the actual winner of American Idol!
So who do we care about? Crystal Bowersox is in a league on her own but i don’t see her selling out arenas or stadiums. Maybe Lilith Fair or other music festivals. Let’s be serious? she is more suited to a chair and her guitar/harmonica which doesn’t suit a huge venue. Aaron Kelly is probably the only one this season who can succeed win or lose because there aren’t a lot of young MALE (i have to put that in caps before someone yells Taylor Swift) country singers under the age of 18! So he could definitely jump in next to Taylor and start a young Country revolution. Who else, Siobhan Magnus? Crazy mad scream at the end, that works and doesn’t work…she can’t just do that in every song or we’d get bored. Michael Lynche? Okay Ruben Studdard 2.0 with a lot of personality and vocals.. but how does he fit in the already saturated rnb/hip hop market! Everyone else has a comparable counterpart to previous Idol seasons and i don’t see any Kelly’s, Adam’s, Carrie’s or Jennifer’s!
This season is a whole lot of been there done that and the dynamics of the judges isn’t helping at all. The four completely different personalities just don’t work together causing a lot of mixed reviews and confusion for both the contestants and the viewers. Ellen is focused on the comedy, Kara is focused on the meaning of the lyrics, Randy is confused, and Simon is the only person who says it as it is whether it hurts the contestant or not. I don’t even know how the judging will move forward without him. At the end of the day, American Idol will continue to be the number 1 show on TV…until of course X-Factor comes to us in the fall of 2011!!!